Munich (June 30, 2020) – The Wirecard shareholders have been through a lot in the past few weeks. First, the accounting scandal comes to light, then the longtime CEO was arrested, and now the group files for insolvency and is facing fraud allegations. The financial service provider said it had opened legal proceedings in Munich ‘due to impending insolvency and over-indebtedness.’
For the first time in history, a business that is part of the German DAX – stock market index consisting of the 30 major German companies trading on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange – goes bankrupt. The Wirecard share price fell by 90 percent after the company’s plans became known. The financial service provider said in a statement on June 25, it had opened legal proceedings in Munich ‘due to impending insolvency and over-indebtedness.’
The $2 billion accounting scandal
Only a few days ago, the burst of a $2 billion accounting scandal shook the digital payments company, crashing its stock, and leading to the arrest of Markus Braun, former CEO for almost two decades, in an accounting-fraud probe. He was released on bail of 5 million euros a day later.
The scandal was revealed when Wirecard said that its long-time auditor, EY, could not locate funds and refused to sign off on the company’s financial results. Thereafter, Wirecard admitted on June 22 that 1.9 billion euros in cash included in financial statements probably never existed in the first place, after Philippine’s central bank denied the money had entered the country’s financial system. It is still completely unclear who is responsible for the air bookings that triggered the misery.
In two banks in the Philippines, there are 1.9 billion euros in accounts on paper – but as it turns out, this money probably doesn’t exist. Subsequently, Wirecard is now faced with, among other things, immense claims for damages. The company sees itself as a victim but EY said the hole in the company’s books was the result of a sophisticated global fraud. According to news agency Reuters, EY said while it was completing the 2019 audit, it was provided with false confirmations with regard to escrow accounts and reported them to the relevant authorities. ‘There are clear indications that this was an elaborate and sophisticated fraud involving multiple parties around the world in different institutions with a deliberate aim of deception,’ EY said.
Braun is accused of having artificially inflated the company’s balance sheet and sales through fake transactions. Authorities believe that he did not act alone: three other managers are also under investigation. Interestingly, Braun already sold a not inconsiderable part of his own Wirecard shares to meet a margin call the week he resigned as CEO.
The insolvency proceeding, the German BaFin and more allegations
The statement Wirecard issued on June 25 also said they are considering whether the insolvency proceedings should be applied to its subsidiaries. Wirecard Bank is not included in the proceedings.
The German regulator BaFin has already appointed a special representative to oversee the bank and ‘the release processes for all payments of the bank will be located exclusively within the bank and no longer at Group level.’
The German BaFin has come under intense pressure itself for its handling of the scandal. The collapse is already prompting calls for a parliamentary inquiry into the government’s responsibility. However, BaFin has also come under fire abroad for not spotting problems sooner. The EU’s markets watchdog will now assess if BaFin’s responses to allegations of improprieties at Wirecard were adequate to protect investor confidence in EU markets, stated a letter from the European Commission, according to Reuters. The Commission asked the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) to undertake a ‘fact-finding analysis’ into BaFin’s response to the allegations and report back no later than July 15.
Wirecard was once much-heralded for its innovation. But in January 2019, its success story already began to unravel. The Financial Times uncovered accounting irregularities in Wirecard’s Asian operations. The British newspaper reported that Wirecard forged and backdated contracts in a string of suspicious transactions in Singapore. Back then, Wirecard denied the report and the authorities in Singapore announced an investigation.
Later last year, the Financial Times suggested that profits and sales had been inflated at Wirecard outposts in Dubai and Ireland. Again, Wirecard denied the allegations. This time, the digital payments company engaged KPMG to run an independent investigation.
KPMG published its findings in April of this year and said that they were unable to verify one billion euros in cash balances, questioned Wirecard’s acquisition accounting, and said Wirecard had not provided enough information to fully explain issues raised by the Financial Times.
Read more: OSC found Quadriga’s mysterious collapse was due to fraud

